2024 09 29 – Road Safety Update
Cllr A. Smith’s Recent Success
Following a concerted effort from Councilor A Smith’s review of Road safety aspects within the Parish we are glad to announce some positive news. The Application to get the Tangmere road reduced to 40mph just east of the Bus stop at Woodfield House has been successful and in fact the whole of the Tangmere road up to the edge of the village is now 40mph.
Unfortunately one rejection has been received to impose a HGV restriction on Marsh Lane and it is the same issue that would be had for other smaller roads in the Parish. Please see the full reasoning below:
Our ref: Traffic Regulation Order application – Marsh Lane – Merston / Oving – 3811650
Thank you for your Traffic Regulation Order (TRO) application for Marsh Lane, Oving. Please quote ref number 3811650 in any future correspondence.
I can now confirm that your TRO application has found its way to myself as the Area Traffic Engineer for the Chichester District.
Please note that the TRO process is a democratic process. This means that any proposal may be implemented in full, in part or declined by the Assistant Director due to objections or representations at the formal consultation stage. Please be aware that funding a proposal does not guarantee that it will be implemented any sooner, if at all. Successful applications will be included on a programme, where further feasibility and design work may take place. A proposal will then be subject to a three-week statutory advertisement or ‘formal public consultation’. In addition to a notice being placed in the local paper, site notices may also be erected at the location of the proposal. Once the formal consultation period is over, a final decision on the TRO may be required by the County Council’s Assistant Director, Highways Transport and Planning. If the TRO is approved, arrangements are made for the necessary signs and road markings to be provided. A final notice will also be advertised in a local paper stating when the TRO will come into effect. In total, it may take approximately 12 months for a TRO application to proceed to implementation.
I have now carried out an Initial Assessment, of which the application has unfortunately failed to progress. I can fully appreciate your concerns about Heavy Goods Vehicles within this area, however the introduction of these moving restrictions is likely to bring minimal benefit at this location. This restriction could end up relocating the traffic and causing a knock-on effect by creating further issues to the highway network, as a secondary route for HGV traffic to use as an alternative will need to be provided. In this instance, it is extremely hard to find an alternative due to the rural location on the outskirts of Chichester. Weight restrictions will not be used if there is no suitable alternative route for the displaced traffic.
This application is deemed to be contentious, given the complexity of the Location Plan you have provided, and the distance of road that this proposal includes. Whilst the resident support that has been obtained is sufficient and has been taken into consideration within the scoring process, applications of this stature need visible proof that the nearby residents are affected by a safety issue that occurs often. It is also likely that this scheme would be more suited as a Community Highway Scheme application, because the installation of signage alone is not always effective and physical measures should be taken to prevent any abuse of the restrictions, however it is again unlikely that this would score well as this mechanism is also scored against a set criteria and schemes are prioritised across the County.
Following further investigation into the section of road aforementioned, the introduction of Weight Restrictions can be imposed for structural or environmental reasons. To clarify, this restriction is a legal control on a specified vehicle weight or width, mainly on lorries, on certain roads and routes. This means that the restriction prevents large vehicles from using inappropriate roads, demonstrating the need for a legal order (Traffic Regulation Order). However, a Traffic Regulation Order in Marsh Lane is not realistic at this location as there is genuine business and resident lorry access required at all times; Refuse vehicles, Delivery vehicles, Removal vehicles, etc. Even with a legal order for a 7.5 tonne Heavy Goods Vehicle prohibition with an ‘Except for Access’ clause, compliance quickly falls into dispute and the restriction is notoriously difficult to enforce.
Police enforcement commands a low priority, and the installation of signs alone is not always effective. It is also evident that by the images you have provided, that the existing “6’<6.6” width restriction in place isn’t being adhered to and this gives the impression that a Weight Restriction is also likely to be ignored, with the installation of additional signs giving minimal enforcement to the legality.
West Sussex County Council do have some areas across the county with a Weight Restriction Traffic Regulation Order and associated signage restricting heavy goods vehicles over 7.5 tonnes from using residential roads, but there is no blanket ban. We would not want a blanket ban anyway, as this would cause the District Council problems when attempting to collect refuse and other needs of access. The majority of areas where weight restrictions are in place, are primarily areas located near industrial / new development estates, with large numbers of HGV movements, and were introduced to deter HGV’s using shortcuts from the prescribed HGV route. This would not be effective within Marsh Lane.
I would also like to add that whilst it is perceived that the installation of Weight Restrictions is thought to remove the route from Sat-Nav, this is not always the case. A West Sussex County Council Network Manager has been in previous correspondence with various companies with HGV drivers using Satellite Navigation, to encourage them to update their navigation systems, as this is a genuine problem countrywide; vehicles taking inappropriate routes, sometimes causing damage to low bridges and other structures. Unfortunately even if Sat-Nav companies comply, individual drivers who do not update their Sat-Nav systems will continue to cause problems by using the route, and many drivers will not comply with existing traffic signs, or drive with due care and attention.
West Sussex County Council Policy Guidance “Living with the Lorry” has an Assessment criteria for the introduction of Weight Restrictions. “Lorries above 7.5 tonnes must comprise of at least 3% of the total vehicle traffic over a 12 hour period (07:00 – 19:00) OR there must be at least 50 lorries above 7.5 tonnes or at least 30 lorries above 17 tonnes using the road in question over a 12 hour period (07:00 – 19:00). Marsh Lane is unlikely to meet the policy criteria for a lorry ban given the geographical location to the nearest A and B roads.
Regarding the general speed of traffic, the ‘Sussex Safer Roads Partnership’ (SSRP) is a good contact point for speed related issues and has funded temporary signs and bin stickers for use in road safety campaigns where speed is considered to be a factor. SSRP work in conjunction with Sussex Police and the theme is one of ‘Slow Down’ in the area and can be specific to a particular speed limit. Information on the process to request such signs or possible cameras in your neighbourhood can be found below:
https://www.sussexsaferroads.gov.uk/page/contact
To conclude, it is important to note that the request for a Weight Restriction comes with a ‘except for access’ clause meaning that routes quickly fall into dispute and are notoriously difficult to enforce. The ‘except for access’ must be installed alongside the regulatory signage as these are needed to permit Heavy Goods Vehicles access to residential properties for deliveries, emergency services and removals etc. It is for this reason that enforcement of these routes are a low priority.
I apologise if this isn’t the outcome you were hoping for at this time and I would recommend contacting Sussex Police via Operation Crackdown to report any breach of the existing Width Restriction on Marsh Lane, and this can be actioned accordingly. More information can be viewed via: https://operationcrackdown.org/
Kind regards,
Traffic Engineer
Western Area (Arun & Chichester)
Highways, Transport and Planning
Place services
West Sussex County Council





